0800 040 7526
It’s a long running debate (excuse the pun), and one which can often come down to personal preference, but who’s the winner in the running outside vs treadmill running contest?
The first thing to consider is energy; or rather, which one requires more and so will get you fitter more quickly? In the running outside vs treadmill running debate the outdoors running camp claim that running outside burns more energy. One of the main factors here is wind resistance – which you don’t get in the gym. So you’d think that running outdoors would be the winner. But in a study by Exeter University, runners were made to run along a road while their energy expenditure was measured. The same volunteers were then made to run on a treadmill, again with energy output being measured, but at varying levels of incline. The study found that by using the incline, treadmill running could be made as strenuous as the street/track variety. A 1-2% gradient was enough to nullify the difference.
Secondly, speed is also a factor. Those running on a treadmill tend to overestimate the speed at which they are going. A Singapore study asked candidates to run outdoors at a particular speed and then match that pace on a treadmill. When they tried this the study showed that even though they thought they had matched the speed on the treadmill, they were actually going markedly slower. The scientists behind the study concluded that on the treadmill, runners lacked visual clues they would have got outdoors that helped them to judge speed.
Safety is also a consideration. Running outdoors can be hazardous due to traffic, other runners, pedestrians and other hazards. However, running on a treadmill also has safety issues. People often nudge the front of the treadmill, especially when coming under physical pressure, slips and falls see runners “spat out the back” as the treadmill shoots them off backwards.
Proprioception – running on a treadmill is very repetitive. This means that the same pressures and same impacts are exerted with every step. This has a two-fold effect. Firstly, it means that repetitive strain injuries are much more common on a treadmill. Secondly, it does little to improve co-ordination and communication between the brain and limbs. The variation of outdoors running, from incline to surface to direction change means that these repetitive strain injuries are less likely; it also improves co-ordination more.
Measurability – the treadmill is precisely measurable. You know exactly how you did from one run to the next as speed, incline, pace and time are all measured accurately. However, with the onset of affordable gps tracking systems and fitness watches, measuring an outdoors run has never been easier.
Well being – it seems fairly obvious that running outdoors will produce greater feelings of well-being and more endorphins. The increased physical challenge produces the latter; variety, greater possibilities for teaming up with other runners and proximity to nature helping the former. Scientists from the same team at Exeter University tried to properly evaluate the evidence and running outdoors was the clear winner.
So which one is better? Most of the evidence points to running outdoors. But the key factor to all exercise should be achievability and enjoyment. If you like to go to the gym and use a treadmill, then go for it. If you like running outdoors better, then stick to that. Whatever makes you more likely to exercise is the real winner! Perhaps a combination off the two, (particularly the treadmill in winter darkness) would be a good option.
How to avoid blisters? It’s easy and cheap. Blisters can be very frustrating. Your body is ready to train hard, you’re all set mentally, but your heel blisters mean that its just to painful to do anything. There are lots of different blister remedies in the market, quite often these are costly too, certainly in the long term.
But a study in the US has found that the most effective way to treat blisters in with simple surgical tape, at around 60p a roll. Just apply the tape to the parts of the feet (or hands) that are affected and off you go.
Grant Lipman, MD, an emergency medicine physician, was a doctor for endurance athletes who were running 25 to 50 miles a day in various parts of the world, from the US to Antarctica to Chile.
Despite the harsh conditions and extreme exercise, the most common complaint that Lipman heard from the athletes was about the pain and debilitation caused by foot.
“What I kept hearing was, ‘Doctor, I’d be doing so well, if only for my feet,’” said Lipman, a clinical associate professor of emergency medicine. “Their feet were getting decimated.”
“People have been doing studies on blister prevention for 30 or 40 years and never found anything easy that works,” said Lipman, who is the lead author of the study. “I wanted to look at this critically,” said the doctor.
For the study, 128 ultra marathon runners had tape applied to just one foot, with no tape applied to the other, before taking part in a 155 mile running event. By the end of the race, only 30 of the taped feet were blistered, compared with 81 for the group with no tape applied. The study found that not only is surgical tape a great way to avoid blisters, it’s also effective for treating existing blisters too.
You may have seen some funny looking tubes lying around in the gym. Some may have grooves and lumps on, some may be smooth, but they are all foam rollers. A foam roller is basically a type of massage tool that you use with your own force and/or bodyweight to massage and “roll” tight parts of your body. A bit like a rolling pin and some stale dough (for stale dough, read tight bands and lumps of muscle), a foam roller will increase blood flow and circulation, as well as help your body breakdown scar tissue and adhesions in the muscles and connective tissue – those nasty knots that can limit your range of motion and lead to repetitive strain injuries. But how to use a foam roller?
Foam rollers have several advantages over traditional sports therapy methods and physiotherapy. It’s cheaper – you do it yourself; you can direct the point of massage with more accuracy as you are both the practitioner and the patient; it’s cost, time and space efficient; it will help to ease knots and tight bands or muscles. It can be (very!) painful, but that just means that you are doing it correctly.
Whatever muscle groups you’re working, don’t forget:
A lot of tension in these muscles can lead imbalances around the hip and knee, leaving you at risk of injury. The TFL, if overly tight, puts excessive strain on the ITB (see below) and can cause a knock-on knee problem.
How to do it:
The roller is a great way to work a tight IT band, which is really hard to stretch on your own and usually causes the common runner’s problem ITB syndrome, where the ITB rubs on the lower knee joint in running and other activities.
How to do it:
Excessive tension and knots in the quads can lead to pain at the back of the knee and can have a surprising effect on the lower back. The quads are often overused when your glutes and hip muscles aren’t working properly.
How to do it:
Place your elbows on the ground underneath your shoulders and roll the whole body of the muscle slowly.
Excessive tension in the calf can cause pain further up the around the knee, but can also lead to injuries and tears of the achilles and MTJ (muscle-tendinous-junction) where the calf joins the achillies tendon.
How to do it:
Have fun (!) now that you know how to use a foam roller!
The benefits of squats – some might promote the benefits of swimming; others might be big running fans. Then there are those that do lots of sit-ups every day. All of these activities are good for us, but there’s one exercise that’s better than them all – squats. Here are some of the benefits of squats.
You can do them anywhere. You don’t need a gym, or expensive equipment. You don’t even need shoes. You can do squats anywhere.
There are lots of different kinds. Jumping squats will add some cardio to your session. Really slow squats will be really safe and difficult. Holding wall squats are great for skiing. Squats are versatile and can incorporate want different aspects of fitness, from cardio to strength to flexibility.
Further reading on the benefits of squats can be found here – and also why squatting to full depth is important.
One of the biggest myths in fitness is that you can spot tone. This means that you can exercise a particular muscle or area and then lose fat and tone up in that one specific place. Thus, if you adhere to this “spot tone” theory, lots of sit ups or crunches will give you a flat tummy. It is, however, a myth. It can’t be done. Sorry. Sit ups will NOT give you a flat tummy
1 – The body works as a whole system. When we lose fat, we lose it from all over, not any one particular place. “But when I lose weight, it comes first from my face and chest” many women will say. This will appear to be the case, but the less fat you have in a given area, the more quickly it will appear to slim down when you lose weight. As a mechanism, we store more fat around the midriff, bottom and thighs. Less on the face, arms and chest. So as you lose weight, it will indeed appear to come first and fastest from these latter areas, but that’s simply because there is less fat there in the first place.
The body will lose fat from everywhere.
2 – Bigger muscles are more important than smaller ones for fat loss. By doing sit ups we can tone the abdominal wall. But, if we are consuming more energy than we expend, we will still be increasing the size of the “fat suit” that covers up that tummy. So despite any toning from the sit ups, they will still be hidden under a layer of fat. To reveal the abs we must instead focus on removing this “fat suit”. We all have a six pack. That’s the way our abs are shaped. We must all have abs, or we wouldn’t be able to get out of bed in the morning. But only through loss of fat will they be revealed. To reveal them, we must expend more than we take in. Exercise-wise, the best way to expend the most calories is to work the biggest muscle groups. The bigger the muscle exercised, the more energy it will need every day.The abdominal wall is a relatively small fascia of muscle. Working it won’t burn that much energy. So, rather than endless crunches, we need to work the large muscle groups like the legs, chest, back and shoulders. So pull ups, push ups, squats and shoulder presses will do much more to reveal and flatten the tummy than sit-ups. With correct nutrition – see below!
3 – Wrong rep range. So, you’re doing all the right exercises as above. When you remove the fat suit you would like to have nice ridged abs under there. So you do endless sit ups. These will help to make the tummy muscles good at endurance, but not make them bigger. To make them bigger you need to do less reps at a greater level of difficulty. Ideally this is 2-5 sets of abdominal exercises where you fail (can’t do any more) at 10 reps. The same goes for the compound legs, back, chest and shoulder exercises mentioned above. The larger and more toned they are, the more lean muscle mass you have. Like a bigger engine in a car, these large muscles will demand more energy all day, every day. Smaller muscles (like biceps and abs), not so much.
4 – Nutrition, nutrition nutrition. To reveal the abs we need to lose fat. The only way to lose fat is to expend more energy than we consume. Thus eating and nutrition are much more important for a flat tummy than sit-ups. All the exercise in the world won’t reveal your abs or remove your fat suit if you are eating more than you expend, and eating poorly at that. Only through creating a deficit, and eating healthy foods low in starch and sugar (that cause fat storage) will we get a flat tummy. Sit ups at this point will be like trying to fix a house by dropping bricks on it from a helicopter.
5 – HIIT. In the overall calorie stakes, high intensity interval training will help to burn the most energy in the least time. Rather than train slowly for a long time in the “fat burning zone”, we need to up the intensity. This will burn more energy, helping to create the all-important deficit, so you lose fat and get a flat tummy.
6 – Poor posture. By folding forwards in the midriff and hunching the shoulders (exactly what we do in sit-ups) we are encouraging poor posture. Part of any good personal training program should include a postural assessment and correctional exercises. Repeatedly bending forwards hundreds of times every week (doing sit-ups) encourages shortening of the tummy, chest and shoulder muscles while lengthening the musculature in the back. This will, over time, lead to rounded shoulders and poor posture.
So if crunches are no good, what should I do? Compound strength training exercises, done reasonably hard with a good weight is what you need. Obviously if you are a beginner then you will need to learn moves like barbell squats and dumbbell bent over rows with a light weight at first, but once you have mastered the basics, moves like chest presses, barbell squats our deadlifts, bent over rows, barbell clean and press will aid muscle growth, upping the metabolic rate. Eat well, with low sugar and starch, create an energy deficit most days (with the odd treat day), and you will burn only fat. Burn enough, and build enough muscle, and your 6 pack will be revealed!
Those of us over 40 know that staying fit and trim seems to require a lot more effort than it did when we were in our 20s. It becomes especially hard to maintain any semblance of a flat tummy. For those athletes among us, training hard for long sessions over most days of the week seems to bring only limited gains; it can actually make us feel lethargic and tired. But read on and learn how to stay fit over 40.
New research by a Welsh Doctor is beginning to show that less is more. Previously fitness and conditioning coach for both the Welsh national rugby team and top 12 club The Scarlets, Dr Peter Herbert is now an exercise physiologist and director of the human performance laboratory at the University of Wales. Deceptively young looking for his age, Dr Herbert’s fit physique is not down to the usual long distance cycling or marathons usually taken up by middle aged men in midlife crises. His toned biceps are instead down to a scientifically proven regimen that is more minimal in approach.
Having taken up indoor cycling and rowing after retiring from rugby coaching, Dr Herbert found that hours and days in the gym training hard seemed to be achieving only diminishing returns.
Science has long known about the slippery slope of health past 40. A man’s maximum heart rate drops by a beat a minute per year after the age of 30; the heart’s capacity to pump blood comes down by 5-10% per decade; an average of 90g of lean muscle is lost each yer past the age of 40 (this decline is greater for women). After 50 these losses accelerate – a 15% drop in testosterone per year means that the male body loses up to 500g of lean muscle per year. This adds up – someone in their 70s doing no exercise will typically have ⅓ less muscle mass than their former 25 year old self.
Intrigued by recent findings showing the benefits if HIIT (high intensity interval training), especially for those previously sedentary and/or with diabetes, Dr Herbert started experimenting with shorter, but less frequent workouts. Using himself as a case study, Herbert cut out all long training sessions, putting a limit of 30 minutes on all lighter paced exercise. He then did just one, near maximal session per week on an exercise bike. Remarkably, his fitness improved.
“Within a couple of months I performed better in cycle races and I felt stronger” he says.
This gain triggered more studies on high intensity low frequency workouts for those over 40, not just for health and fitness but also to avoid niggles that become more common as we age. In one study, published in the American Gerontology Society Journal, Herbert recruited 20 hardcore veteran athletes from their mid 50s to their mid 70s who were training for competitive rowing, squash, cycling and triathlon events. He got them to stop training daily and follow his plan. A drastic reduction in training volume meant only one near maximal session every 5 days doing 6-10 30 second sprints on an indoor cycle. On days off exercise was allowed, but only “active recovery” in the form of 20-30 minutes of gentle aerobic activity.
The results were conclusive; there were large gains in VO2 max (maximum lung capacity), body fat dropped and leg strength improved by an average of 15%. This last gain was particularly significant, as leg strength has been linked to heart health and longevity in recent studies. The “fit-HIIT” also boosted levels of testosterone, meaning reduced loss of lean muscle mass.
Herbert says: “every 5 days I work to 90% of maximum capacity and then tick over, burning calories with gentle exercise”. He recently won bronze at the World masters Cycling Championships, and says he feels stronger and fitter than ever.
How does it work?
If you are new to exercise then some pre conditioning will be needed. Doing maximal intervals when coming from nothing isn’t advisable. This could be:
Week 1: walk 8-10 minutes a day (brisk pace)
Week 2: Walk or cycle 10-12 minutes a day
Week 3: walk or cycle for 15 minutes a day.
Week 4: walk or cycle for 20 minutes a day
Week 5: alternate days – day 1 – 20 minutes of cycling or fast walking. Day 2 – 4 minutes of walking or slow cycling with 3 minutes of faster cycling or jogging.
Week 6: alternate days – day 1 – 20 minutes of cycling or fast walking. Day 2 – 3 minutes of steady walking or cycling followed by 1 minute of faster running or cycling. This minute should be between 65-75% of flat out.
Then you’re ready for FIT-HIIT!
Days 1-3: 20 minutes of steady state jogging, rowing or cycling
Day 4: 20 minutes of very gentle aerobic exercise with 10 minutes of stretching.
Day 5: either 6 by 30 second sprints (flat out) with 3 minutes of comfortable recovery OR 6 by 20 second sprints with just 30s of gentle recovery for the more advanced.
Women who are older but have strong legs will do better when it comes to ageing of the brain, shows a study of more than 300 twins.
Researchers at King’s College in London showed that leg strength is a good marker of whether a person is getting enough exercise. In turn these levels of exercise have a strong link to brain health.
The study, published in the journal Gerontology, suggests that exercise releases chemicals into the brain that help to boost cognitive power in the elderly. Scientists tracked the health of over 15o pairs of twins aged between 43 and 73 (at the beginning of the study). Leg power was measured at the start of the study using a specially adapted gym machine. Brain power was then assessed using computer-based tasks that tested both memory and mental processing skills.
10 years later at the end of the study, the brain tests were repeated. The twin with greater leg power (and thus an assumption of greater overall fitness) had better cognitive power than the weaker sibling, even with other lifestyle factors that might usually increase chances of dementia.
Alzheimer’s Society director of research Dr Doug Brown said the study added to the growing evidence that physical activity could help look after the brain as well as the body.
“However, we still don’t fully understand how this relationship works and how we can maximise the benefit,” he said.
Lead researcher Dr Claire Steves said: “When it came to cognitive ageing, leg strength was the strongest factor that had an impact in our study.
All exercise is good for you, just about. Unless you plan to do 10 marathons back to back (this will make your knees hurt) any activity you do that elevates your heart rate and is more than sitting will bring lots of health benefits. Walking, for example has been shown to be hugely beneficial for health (physical and mental) and disease prevention.
But not all exercise is useful if you are trying to lose weight. Some exercise can actually make you fatter, if you have bought into the myth. We see this all the time; a client signs up for a yoga class. Now, we’ve nothing against yoga, it’s a great way to exercise both mind and body. But most types will not significantly increase your metabolic rate or burn enough calories to help you lose weight. So if you go to yoga and then reward yourself with a cake upon return, it may actually make you fatter.
So what is the best exercise for weight loss? Here are the big 6.
Why these won’t make you thin:
Yoga: A typical yoga session burns just 130 calories, or the same as a brisk walk. We’re not saying it’s not good for you, just not the best for fat loss.
Pilates: According to the American Council on exercise, a typical pilates class did not meet the recommendations for improving basic cardio-respiratory fitness. Even advanced pilates burned just 254 calories per hour, the same as most gentle aerobic activity. Great for core strength, posture and a stable back; not so much for fat loss.
Jogging. The slower you go, the more impact up and down on the knees. The slower you go the less energy used. Cut the time, add the speed.
Powerplate. Just useless. Standing on it vibrating hard will use the same calories as thinking about a big mac.
We don’t all have an hour to get to the gym, exercise and get back, but there is so much that you can do at home. Even with no equipment there are plenty of exercise that will challenge and improve all aspects of your fitness, from strength, bone density, cardio-vascular fitness, balance and co-ordination. Modern studies also shoe that you can get just about all the fitness and health gains from exercise in just a few minutes provided you go at a high intensity.
Here is a little 7 minute workout that anyone can do with minimal equipment (boys – 8-12kg kettlebell, girls 5-8kg). Be sure to do a 2 minute warm up first by doing some step ups, a few squats, and some arm and leg mobilisation (basically fling arms and legs around a few times!).
The 10 minute workout – try to take only 15 seconds maximum between exercises. Try to do as many repetitions as you can on each one (it has to be hard at the end to force adaptive change) and do a brief stretch when you have done 2 rounds.
1 – Push ups (beginner from the knee, advanced full)
2 – Stepping lunge – hold the kettlebell at the chest for greater difficulty.
3 – Kettlebell throw
4 – Star jumps (jumping jacks for beginners)
5 – One arm bent over row (both sides!)
6 – Squat to shoulder press, one arm
7 – Russian twist
8 – Kettlebell throws
9 – Burpees ( beginners use a step, chair or sofa to raise the hands and decrease difficulty)
Although the thought of stepping out for a run might fill you with dread, even on a sunny summer’s day, if you really think about it running is better than sex for a variety of reasons. Here are the top 10!
1 – You can choose exactly when you want to do it. Accessibility is one of the huge plus points for running. You don’t need a gym to do it, or a bedroom for that matter. And unlike sex (the sort we are talking about anyway) it’s just you, so there’s no waiting for anyone else.
2 – You can do it as often as you like. Forget getting turned down, again. With running you can do it 7 days a week, although remember that inprovement needs some recovery, so at least a day of rest per week would be a good idea.
3 – You can do it pretty much anywhere, without getting arrested. Again running wins over most other forms of exercise on availability, cetrainly including bedroom antics.
4 – You will burn more calories. The weight bearing nature of running and the sheer impact and shock of it burns more calories than almost any other form of exercise. Especially the type that you get lying down. Obviously the faster you run the more calories you will get through.
5 – You will improve bone density. As above, the weight bearing nature of running and the loads involved means that your body is forced to adapt, including maintaining strong bones.
6 – You can post photos of yourself doing it online. No-one will get upset, even your wife or husband.
7 – No-one will be shocled if you do it in a group. You can even give your car keys to someone else for safe keeping while you do it.
8 – You will get the same, or even more endorphins, putting you in a good mood for the rest of the day. Exercise, especially the higher intensity and weight bearing type, releases feel-good hormones including dopamine and endorphines.
9 – Minimal equipment needed. Unlike fifty shades of grey you don’t need stirrups, hammocks or whips. Just a good pair of trainers and off you go.
10 – It’s actually good for the knees. Forget carpet burns; running, in the vast majority of cases, will improve the strength and stability of your knees, improving connective tissue strength, the strength of supporting muscles, and balance, amongst others.
So even if you have never run before, and feel that it’s not for you, give it a go. There may even be a secret runner in there. If you are a complete beginner or feel you are too heavy for running, just step out and commit to a fast walk. Add in some very short intervals of jogging, build it from there! Remember that running is better than sex.